The Manufacture
of the Subject
The industrialization of socialization — how a human subject is produced, station by station, on a line that runs from crib to deathbed.
Life-time
value
The marketer has a phrase for it: life-time value. The projected return on a customer if every moment of a life can be commodified, crib to deathbed. Read it slowly. It is an accounting category, and the asset it books is a human life.
Capital still wants the working day, but its frontier has moved inward — to attention, to affect, to desire. Behavioral surplusZuboff: private experience claimed, unilaterally and without the asking, as free raw material — rendered into behavioral data and sold forward as prediction. is what the meters read. Psychic surplusThe capacity to feel, imagine, want, play, attach. Broader than behavioral surplus — it is what the meters are clamped to. is what the meters are clamped to.
ACTIVE
The cradle is
the first room of
a long enclosure
A two-year-old who cannot manage a spoon can manage a touchscreen. The gesture comes before the grammar, the swipe before the sentence. Hand the child the tablet and the crying stops — which is the whole point — and the autoplay queue advances on its own so the stopping never has to end.
The licensed character arrives as a child’s first love: a transitional object that, unlike the worn blanket, is owned upstream and renewed on a release schedule. Play arrives pre-scripted. Imagination is routed down storylines that terminate, reliably, at a checkout.
I call the mechanism gadgetized mediationSelimović: the technological interface through which a child's earliest libidinal processes are modulated by something that is also, quietly, a meter.. The educational app that teaches the alphabet also logs the taps. The gap between an impulse and its gratification — the interval where a child once learned that wanting can be tolerated — thins toward zero.
= relief
Repressive desublimationMarcuse: repression gives way to discharge — the drive released on terms that defuse it, its charge spent in the same motion.: the restless energy that once found mischief is spent on a video. Nothing is forbidden. Everything is channeled. The charge is exactly the part that might have gone somewhere unscripted.
Before the child can speak the sentence, the child is hailed by it — you are someone who wants this — and answers, through the body, yes.
If childhood plants
the appetite,
youth is the harvest
The libido surges in every direction at once — sexual, social, identitarian — and an apparatus stands ready that has spent decades learning the shape of that surge. Games, feeds, streams and pornography compose a single psychic economy around the adolescent, and underneath the play runs a steady extraction.
Scholars named the condition playborPlay that is also work. The player's libidinal investment is the labor that makes the product — paid back in the token pleasures the product doles out.. The same operation runs through the feed, where it is harder to see because it looks like friendship. A friendship starts to feel like an audience to be kept.
Sexual desire is captured on the same logic and at a scale without precedent. The recommendation engine learns a body’s responses and feeds them back amplified — escalating, because escalation holds the session open. A surge of curiosity meets its video before it has finished forming as a question.
The most private experience a person has becomes a predictive signal, priced. The passion that might have funded an upheaval is booked, in advance, against consumption.
A Skinner box,
upholstered
as convenience
It does not command. It offers — endlessly, in a register tuned to the individual — a marketplace of satisfactions wide enough to feel like the open world, and arranged so that every path returns to the work-and-spend.
The next autoplay. The next you might also like. The next match served at the hour the model knows the loneliness peaks. The desires that result are co-authored, half mine and half the algorithm’s, and the seam between the longing I arrived with and the one that was waiting for me is the thing I can no longer find.
And the pharmaceutical industry has moved into the regulation of affect itself. Preciado’s name for the regime is the pharmacopornographicPreciado: power has stopped saying no to sex and started saying — have all you want, on our molecule, by our protocol. Government has reached the level of the dose.: pleasure is provisioned, metered through the substance and the device.
Participation in one’s own extraction is experienced, from the inside, as self-fulfilment. The enjoyment is real. It is the binding agent.
Marcuse named it decades ago, and the phrase still fits — a “comfortable, smooth, reasonable, democratic unfreedom,” held in place by the difficulty of imagining the alternative from inside a life this padded.
Try, now, to want something the apparatus did not suggest.
The hold it finds
is the clinic
The aging of the body is rewritten as a sequence of treatable deficits, each with a product: the pill that restores function, the hormone therapy, the testosterone marketed against “Low T,” the shelf of anti-aging supplements that sells decline back as a thing one failed to prevent.
A person disappointed by a life might once have taken the disappointment to a church, a movement, a kitchen table. Now it is far likelier to be taken to a prescriber and adjusted at the level of serotonin. The discontent is individualized into a chemical correction that keeps the person consuming — and leaves untouched the conditions that produced the ache.
An eighty-year-old who joins a feed to see her grandson becomes, in the same instant, a fresh target for the insurers and the device-makers, and a newly legible source of data on a cohort that had been dark.
The exit has no outside. It is booked as an input.
The surplus
is ours
Stiegler called the result symbolic misery: the means of producing one’s own symbols, one’s own desires, one’s own way of wanting, ceded to an industry that produces them on one’s behalf. Zuboff calls the data side of it a coup — a seizure of the right to the future, decided above our heads.
Here is the catch the hopeful version leaves out. Knowing the loop does not release you from the loop. The reader who finishes this will pick up the phone before the resentment cools.
And yet — there are seams. Children misuse their toys in ways no focus group sanctioned. People still love each other off the record, where no data is generated. The old withdraw into a quiet the market cannot price.
The surplus is the one resource the circuit cannot make for itself. It must therefore take it from us. That is where the fight is.
—
reg #07 · cashier: THE ALGORITHM · acct #00-0000-0001
A drive that becomes something made instead of something bought.
The materials are modest and mostly old: time that no one is metering, the right to be bored, a room with no feed running in it, work whose reward is the work and the people doing it beside you. Whether we keep enough of it to matter is not something the map can tell us. It is the work the map is for.